Extra procedural protection includes the measures of physical technical witness protection, encompassed by witness protection program. 2. The secret agent and the employee as the witness.


Чтобы посмотреть этот PDF файл с форматированием и разметкой, скачайте файл и откройте на своем компьютере.
МИНИɋɌЕРɋɌВО ОȻРАЗОВАНИЯ НАɍКИ РОɋɋИЙɋКОЙ ɎЕȾЕРАЦИИ ɎЕȾЕРАЛЬНОЕ ОȻРАЗОВАНИЮ РОɋɋИЙɋКОȽО ȽОɋɍȾАРɋɌВЕННОȽО ɌОРȽОВО ЭКОНОМИЧЕɋКОȽО ɍНИВЕРɋИɌЕɌА НАɍЧНЫЙ ЖɍРНАЛ Моɫкɜɚ www.rsute.ru ЖɍРНАЛА РОɋɋИЙɋКОȽО ȽОɋɍȾАРɋɌВЕННОȽО ɌОРȽОВО ЭКОНОМИЧЕɋКОȽО ɍНИВЕРɋИɌЕɌА ПРЕȾɋЕȾАɌЕЛЬ РЕȾАКЦИОННОȽО ɋОВЕɌА ȻАȻɍРИН ɞокɬоɪ юɪиɞичɟɫкиɯ нɚɭк пɪоɮɟɫɫоɪ ɪɟкɬоɪ Роɫɫийɫкоɝо ɝоɫɭɞɚɪɫɬɜɟнноɝо ɬоɪɝоɜо экономичɟɫкоɝо ɭниɜɟɪɫиɬɟɬɚ Аɛɚлкин Ȼоɪоɞин Ȼɚлɭɟɜ Ȼɭɝинɫкий Ȼɭɪлɚцкий Ȼɭɪмиɫɬɪоɜ Воɫкɪɟɫɟнɫкий Ƚɟɪɚщɟнко Ƚлɟɛоɜɚ Ƚоликоɜɚ Ƚɪɟɮ Зɭɛкоɜ Кɚɪпоɜ Кɟɪимоɜ Коэн ɋɬиɜɟн Мɚнɫɭɪоɜ Нɚɛиɭллинɚ Оɫипоɜ Пɚɪɚмоноɜɚ Рɟзɝо Рокɟцкɚя ɋɟнɬюɪин ɋлиɫкɚ ɋɬɟпɚшин Ɍɟɪɟɯ Ɍɪошин ɍɪɫɭл Ɏɟɞоɪоɜ ɏɪиɫɬɟнко Шɟɜцоɜ Шɚмɯɚлоɜ Шимɚнɫкий Якɭнин Яɪочкин Жɭɪнɚл ɜключɟн пɟɪɟчɟнь ɜɟɞɭщиɯ ɪɟцɟнзиɪɭɟмыɯ нɚɭчныɯ жɭɪнɚлоɜ ɚɬɬɟɫɬɚционной комиɫɫии ВАК пɭɛликɚция коɬоɪыɯ оɛязɚɬɟльнɚ ɞокɬоɪɫкиɯ кɚнɞиɞɚɬɫкиɯ ɞиɫɫɟɪɬɚций ВАɋИЛЬЕВɋКИЕ ЦЕННОɋɌИ ɋОВРЕМЕННОȽО ОȻЩЕɋɌВА МЕЖȾɍНАРОȾНАЯ НАɍЧНО ПРАКɌИЧЕɋКАЯ КОНɎЕРЕНЦИЯ ОКɌЯȻРЯ ȽОȾА           ,                    -       .................................................8      !     "               # ..............32 ЭКОНОМИКА  .. $              %  "!   .....37   ..      !  ......................42     .............................................48 Ежɟмɟɫячный нɚɭчный жɭɪнɚл Изɞɚɟɬɫя ɝоɞɚ : Изɞɚниɟ зɚɪɟɝиɫɬɪиɪоɜɚно Миниɫɬɟɪɫɬɜом пɟчɚɬи ɬɟлɟɪɚɞиоɜɟщɚния ɫɪɟɞɫɬɜ мɚɫɫоɜой коммɭникɚции ɋɜиɞɟɬɟльɫɬɜо ɪɟɝиɫɬɪɚции ɫɪɟɞɫɬɜ мɚɫɫоɜой инɮоɪмɚции июля ɍЧРЕȾИɌЕЛЬ Ƚоɫɭɞɚɪɫɬɜɟнноɟ оɛɪɚзоɜɚɬɟльноɟ ɜыɫшɟɝо пɪоɮɟɫɫионɚльноɝо оɛɪɚзоɜɚния Роɫɫийɫкий ɝоɫɭɞɚɪɫɬɜɟнный ɬоɪɝоɜо экономичɟɫкий ɭниɜɟɪɫиɬɟɬ ɝлɚɜноɝо ɪɟɞɚкɬоɪɚ ɋɟмьяноɜ Аɞɪɟɫ ɪɟɞɚкции Моɫкɜɚ ɋмольнɚя Ɍɟл www.rsute.ru E-mail: [email protected] ɪɟɞɚкции ɪɟɞɚкционноɝо ɫоɜɟɬɚ можɟɬ ɫоɜпɚɞɚɬь ɬочкой ɚɜɬоɪоɜ пɭɛликɚции Пиɫьмɟнноɟ ɫоɝлɚɫиɟ ɪɟɞɚкции пɟɪɟпɟчɚɬкɟ ɬɚкжɟ циɬиɪоɜɚнии жɭɪнɚл Вɟɫɬник оɛязɚɬɟльны Рɟɞɚкция ɜɫɬɭпɚɟɬ пɟɪɟпиɫкɭ ɚɜɬоɪɚми Поɞпиɫной инɞɟкɫ кɚɬɚлоɝɟ Роɫпɟчɚɬь Поɞпиɫɚно пɟчɚɬи 11.03.2010. Ɏоɪмɚɬ Ȼɭмɚɝɚ оɮɫɟɬнɚя Ƚɚɪниɬɭɪɚ Оɛъɟм Ɍиɪɚж экз Изɞ 110. Ɍип ɫɜоɛоɞнɚя Оɬпɟчɚɬɚно Изɞɚɬɟльɫɬɜɟ Роɫɫийɫкоɝо ɝоɫɭɞɚɪɫɬɜɟнноɝо ɬоɪɝоɜо экономичɟɫкоɝо ɭниɜɟɪɫиɬɟɬɚ Моɫкɜɚ ȽɋП ɋмольнɚя Роɫɫийɫкий ɝоɫɭɞɚɪɫɬɜɟнный ɬоɪɝоɜо экономичɟɫкий ɭниɜɟɪɫиɬɟɬ 4    3(41), 2010  .. (              ...........................55  .. "                    .........................................................................64   ..,   .. )     :    !    ....................71   .. *          ................................................77  .. +     :        ..............................................85 !"# .. *       !                   ....................................................92 )   !               ...................................................................................100  .. "     !  !        ...........106 ɌОРȽОВЛЯ #         !    %  ...114 &$ . .,   '.. *  !!            -    !   !   .......................................119 "      (     '   ........................................................................................126 ȽОɋɍȾАРɋɌВО ПРАВО     !      # .................133 /           -     ..................................................................................................140 #               ........................................................................................148     3(41), 2010 ;             !  ..................................................................................155  -  %       !    !         ...............................163 ОȻРАЗОВАНИЕ НАɍКА * ' -    '    %''         .................................................171 Abstracts ...............................................................................................181 DATA OF AUTHORS (    ! ...............................................................................187    '      &#x;000;    +  =; .........................................................190 "      .....................................................................191 6    3(41), 2010 PERFORMANCES Pajkovic E. Role and protection of an undercover agent as a witness and cooperative witness in the light of new criminal-procedure legislation of montenegro .............................8 Problems of perfection of the mechanism of realization of the foreign trade legislation of the Russian Federation .............................................................32 Bekzhanova T.K.     3(41), 2010   3(41), 2010         3(41), 2010 Podgorica, Montenegro    2.    !" "" #!$ In criminal proceedings, more than in any other, there is general correctly established. State of facts which is established with the help of to correspond to the truth. Evidence can be original 0direct1 and derivative 0indirect1. witness is every person who, regardless of his7her legal status, has    & 6#    J period of time, with a possibility of members, i.e. to gather data that alone can serve as evidence in criminal proceedings against the members of that group 0personal documents, substantive evidence, recordings of conversations and other1 or to be heard as a Undercover agent is a citizen who, based on the order by an investigative judge, gathers data and evidence provide by means of the law the framework of precise and legally predicted conditions, only in justified and necessary cases, according to the estimation of court and with prescribed control of such measures May bring the mentioned person in danger, under There is not an ideal witness, but his7her participation in criminal proceedings can be of multiple importances, since his7her   &"% That is the reason why it was necessary to improve the damaged party in criminal proceedings, proceedings and, beside the rights familiar to older scholar literature, to provide special measures of protection for these persons from threatening and or other persons outside of the proceedings. do this by certain ratified international documents, not to mention that this issue has Thus, we speak about witness protection by procedural and measures. Basic criterion of their differentiation that are undertaken, i.e. the manner of providing protection. Procedural protection is provided by measures of procedural character, it is related to a questioning a witness and specific way of taking can beH hiding the identity of a witness from the general public, and exceptionally from the defense, as well as measures of prevention of a physical Z )   %    6) 6#,   !')     ! & ) !". )" " !$   "(H , "  %$  "    , /$ "( 7   %  &  %  !/( !"( ! (.  + 7 &$ %  ( )  , & 7  $, & /  !'% %  ( & %  ! #   &  %.   3(41), 2010 of a case, are gathered in this manner with the least intrusion on the right to privacy. These provisions refer to their subsidiary character.   ! ) )"   #, This also means that the mentioned measures can be applied only would not have any justification if the State Prosecutor had enough gathered evidence for In practice it is necessary to make the application of specific certain guaranteed human rights, while, on the other side, these measures logics of events, From the aspect of human rights protection, the question of  + & # !   %(  = 6 ; % d ) ) #  /  &   "( !. %     & "), !   ")   ! &,  &,      !%  '  '  $/(    #7"" (   '   .   %, " $/  / !%  .   )     &,    " %  !%       )  & &  '% ) +) #, .. '%   & "), ") ,   , & !%  % %     " $ 5!  .  %  &  )  , $  !, &  $ & &  !)   )'  % )  8  &   #  / )   &  %  / &$/   %.   %  &    !( (  ) , &!" ! &  !  !/, &  %, &$/  ,  ,  '% !    %  7 '%,        '%  !/$    !%   %  %. , !(  " /" % ! &,     % #, &$/  .   3(41), 2010   ) . is needed for the realization Threatening most often occurs in organized crime cases repenters , collaborators of justice, witnesses under immunity or Grown witnesses. The Montenegrin criminal5procedure legislation, in the framework of provisions on the procedure for criminal acts committed introduces the institute of a cooperative criminal organization, against whom a criminal charge has been brought or criminal Before the description of legal provisions on a cooperative institute of a Grown witness all witnesses received many privileges if they gave testimonies against inability to testifyJ a person who cannot 0due to certain characteristics   &$/  ,   Organized criminality or crime, as a type of criminality, is in may not be a person for whom there is a organizer or leader of a criminal group. ^egarding the status of a cooperative witness in criminal proceedings that a   of relationship The only obligation of a cooperative witness is to speak truth and give statement about everything that is familiar to him7her and not to % $ % "  H % %    [email protected]%% # ",  "%     ( %(, &"(  %$ %, &$/   " -!  (  !  % ,  !"  ",      # ,   3(41), 2010   What should we say in the end of this brief overview on the measures protectionY Normative basis for the implementation of result is always uncertain. But, we should wait for a certain period   3(41), 2010    ..* . 2   ZQ  K. R. %   3(41), 2010 ') +& , $5     3(41), 2010     3(41), 2010           ..* //56   # Q Q 1 0 1 ( 0 r C Q   # q r r I Q Q 1 ) !  5 1 Q Q  [email protected] # 5 % &) #   !  5  6&  [email protected] 5  #  #$ 5 [email protected]  "(    !/  !   5   !  .  ! + " , !  "   )    !    , ' $/) ! ,  + %# & %   !  !" & !   & . !  r  !"     3(41), 2010 -# Q ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( n Y TP C T Q Q Q Q Q Q ) !  &) 0 1 ( Q I I r C Q q !  %  , &    & % !  r  %  /   " "( ),    !(  %.   % ( ) )  % % ' ) !" "'    !%  !   //56 I R & (  5 T Q I    d i R Q ) (  #   3(41), 2010  1  200220032004200520062007 1.-      21,437,325,018,532,341,9 2.         3,69,015,415,411,26,6 29,121,012,024,427,513,6 4.  !     !  14,310,97,711,"3,20,0 5. # $-%&  ! % % - $'    , !  !  31,621,224,331,84,00,9 6. (% % $'    12,64,10,423,518,80,0 7. )      40,136,640,622,836,136,9 8. '      7,27,80,012,411,76,5 9. *        7,410,633,00,041,031,0 + : / ;    . %., 2008.  2       !" # 20062007 .  #  20062007 ==,  !.  10 213,711 255,510 734,6  !    ,  !.  525365105881,5 �  !      ==, ? 51,457,854,8 + : / ;    .%., 2008. � :,[=91 C,J  :,=[9 % R - . ., 2 . ., 2 .R. - " #5 . . Z")  2( 77% +5   3(41), 2010    . .* ") 6 ")  , "   3(41), 2010 //56   3(41), 2010 //56  1 $  #  &        [4]  #  (  1   9- 123456789 [email protected]         227911510191       %4,976,114,055,545,235,215,9 2.ABC         271295282       %4,855,824,375,825,675,495,72 3./          244561228224       %4,916,254,555,574,834,814,8 4.D          71631820205       %5,696,514,445,425,095,165,51 5.B          1291531915       %5,515,915,45,855,1165,44 6.= %           151448113612       %4,845,824,675,575,635,564,89 7.E&. ;          47211321431815       %4,185,385,485,384,395,324,71 8.F           61959161518       %5,715,415,85,645,165,324,59 9.+          71508435783243       %3,6644,214,774,024,433,5 10.;          8060677567546       %3,513,545,723,684,223,073,44 11.G         114613343607459       %2,973,524,954,444,23,13,28   3(41), 2010 ", ",  ' $  Z R -. .      !5 .. '+& % %   65   3(41), 2010 #  ,    3(41), 2010 //56   3(41), 2010 [email protected]5"( #5"( //56   3(41), 2010 //56 index.phpYD?C. 2##%  & #5+&5  % Z ) ) Q#  9:9: .   %   Z ) ) Q#  [` %!% 9::C . ~ [==95.9.    . Z  H 77 www.wolsu.ru7rus7structure7IDAT7vst9::C7:;:9:;.pdf. 2 . ~ ;9 0~ ;;=;1  99.:9.9::=.;. 2- { .. 8(" # }}I . .H 85   3(41), 2010  ..* &) %  , +" (  %   ) !$) #   % 6 !$ Z ) ) Q# ��)    6 !$. K%   / %       6  //56   3(41), 2010 //56 ( (),  "   3(41), 2010 ���% !" "  % %  %  Q5 &)   &5)  { ! Z 5� ) ) Q# J . [[;9.   ), Z %   ZQ  9; %% 9::: . ~ [:`5  &)   & (    6 !$ [:J . 9:9?.      #  % (    6 !$   &)  & 0 21.  %  , &!" '    %"  !) !"H "(,  &   (  ( , 5(, "  &  % //56   3(41), 2010 //56   3(41), 2010 �����`. Z %   ZQ  [`.:`.[C ., ~ `:5 - 6 %)  (  &) $    5% 6 !$ 77 !   ��ZQ. [C. ~ ;. C. R] 2- E.V.J  . . . &). H 5  Z 2- .. 2&)    !$   -Z- ..   ") 6 ") H 5   3(41), 2010                3(41), 2010 !"" " //56 #5 #)   3(41), 2010 #5 #)  "&) 5 $ 6"    +   !      5 )'   " /$ !  !5     5H&#x;.T;&#xj 1.;⌤&#x -1.; TD;&#x .25;) T;&#xw ;&#x;&#x;&#x ";&#x&;&#x ;&#x5T;&#xj -1;&#x.232; -1;&#x.2 T; .2;ͨ ;&#xTw ;&#x$ 6;&#x";&#x  ;&#x;&#x ;&#x+ ;&#x Tj ;&#xT* 1;&#x.151; Tw;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x!;&#x;&#x Tj ;&#xT* -;&#x.000; Tw;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x  ;&#xTj T;&#x* .5;ࡴ ;&#xTw ;&#x';&#x ;&#x ;&#x ;&#x";&#x;&#x Tj ;&#xT* .;䁸&#x Tw ;&#x ;&#x/$;&#x ;&#x!;&#x;&#x ;&#x!5Tj;&#x T* ;&#x.094; Tw;&#x ;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x ;&#x ;&#x ;&#xTj T;&#x* 0 ;&#xTw ;&#x;&#x;&#xHTj ;&#x/F10;&#x 1 T; .0;Ȓ ;&#x-2.4;&#x TD ;&#xROIC;&#x A R;&#xOE B;&#x D4 ; /@;&#x B 0;ROIC A ROE B D4 F /@ B -G, H ROE !  !5 "    % & %     0Z1. ",  $/ . " , ($/ /  !  %%   !" , ! %"$/ +66  )  !   !   .. ;J . [9[.  % !" 5 & % !" & 5  5 ROIC& A A [" B D=' F 'G B #"    5 //56 B DH' F 'G] B D4 F /@ B�B -G WJCC. +           &   '  & "( 65"( ), $&$/( 65 " "  #),  #)  6 ) % .(   +  6" %  ( !   5$ "( /  !     +66  % !" 5. - " 6 5%%  ! , ,  , !&   !  ! 5 %%$ %  % 5  #" "&.  + #%  5   (  !   $ ,  , ! !$ #$     $ 5 % !"    !  5 ) ! %   5 .  &   #    5"( #) % %%     5  +66   5% !  EWG  %%  !5  WG,  %5  )  #. 8  $ !5 " & % 65    "  )  5H !     5& 01  ! "( &#xJ . ;&#x[`00;   [J . [CJ J . [`.K%  &!" # +665   % !  %   6" # t t WC GM E !/% +66   5 !/)      %% &  %5   3(41), 2010 , i t i WC GM E i +66   5     #  !5 4 3 2 1       n  n t t  t n t t   t  ) E ( COF E d CIF  1 1 1 1 1 1 1     2   1 3 t t  t COF t t   t d CIF  X 1 4     #) % J CF  t t    ) 6)   #) %  %%. -   , '$/) /$   "(   /$   "( % !)  "(  "(     " ), %"( , !   , "( "%      &  '   &  [9, , 1 t ( $ !"(   #"( "( //56 /)  '!" ! , +  #" "  -Z-2 R.R.   +66   % ., 2 .,  K.   )H . 222 R .. & ) &.  . ..,  .X. !" +  6  .., ] ..  "  % +665   3(41), 2010   ..*   ..** -#%  6 "),  + $.  )    %"( #) " %% % %  / , %, 6#)  , $    #  !/ .  "   "( //56  "  & ) #J 5"(,    ) #)     !.  # , "  " " %$ +66 6# #  #$    &,  %,   (   (% "  %   % #%   , '%  ,  !  [email protected] $/( # ) 2. 2,  "%     " #  !/ , /  5#&  (   5$ " $& %   " #"( %)  #   ) 6#%  % " . -  "( !& (   U.   ) !. #"( !#. 2    %   %  % &      [J . 99.   3(41), 2010  %% #5 5" //56 �4U. X !. 2   % & % #) # #,   #"(  #"( [email protected]. K") ( % 5,   '% %   !  0 5) 1 # #) #.�4V.  ) !. K") (  !  5  $ 5 ! ( , 5, #),  %/( %   6   %, $/( $ #5$ 6    5%.   ") (  / % %  6  5 .20.  #  !. -#%  & , "  5" (". 6#5#&"   3(41), 2010  1      :  #    $ 1.� -  -    H(;I D   , $- 2.D   -  - 3.J$-  - 4. -  - 5.-  !   - A  ,  - 6.C -    - 7.A-    -   ,  - 8.+  -    -   , - 9./  -    - A  ,  - 10.C-    -   , - 11.A-  !   -   , - //56 $ 12.; -    - 13.A -  - D   , $- 14.A -  -   ,  - 15.  -  !    - 16.A -  !    - 17./-  !    -   ,  - 18.#   !    -   ,  - 19.A -  !(%'    -   , - 20.G-     - Z-]  .. -#% . .H  5KR R, 2., 2 Z. K    #) ;. -Z X 2 .R. % 6%  #) .. 2   &% 77 & . 25 ?. --R K R . -. -#%  . .H   3(41), 2010   ..* #  ) , #" //56   3(41), 2010 =  )  $ $ " %%, 5 " %%, 5 ;   //56 #5"(   3(41), 2010 //56 K% % ) "   . K !"  )  , ")  !   % % %     ,    5 "( 6 "(  ) "( %), "(   !   (. $ #) % . ) !) "  & ), $/(   3(41), 2010 #  $& % &  & . "( ! $/( #  & + %   / % % , ,  & !$"(  . & !  %$ ' " % (, ( ", ! 5!". "( #,  "(  #% #"( )   , &  %')  &  %. *& $    '$ &  % /)   %( ",    //56   3(41), 2010 2  . .* ) , !( % & , //56   ) (  %(  "5'" !% % / % 6.   , +  0,  , "  ) !( $1 !    %&   5#$ ! 5# , &     / ) +   . 25 , &   5   %   " % ! 5 ), " (%     5% , %    6 "( 5. , #, " "(   &)   &5)    5" "  $ 5% !(  % !   05 )'( 6"( !, , $5 ), 5 ),  $ 5&    5  !%  %  % #"( !   "   !1   3(41), 2010 % !" 5  / $  ( "(  ( 5%(. - !      % "5"( #"( !/  5) $ 6  , [email protected]%$/( !' "( "( ),  //56 [email protected] J   3(41), 2010   ( 5  %')  %%5 % )  !  '"( 6 "(  ##)  Z . 4        "  6 5       !5    6   . 4"  H $   !/5 %   &   !5  "(     %& "(  &(J &$ $ $ 6#$  !  % 6     $    !'" 56#"  &        5 , %  ,  %, 5'& J  & &5 $ /  # 5  J $ % !!)   5 ,  &"5$/)  [?: )  5 ) (   "( .Z ) )   5(  0 R1  5&  "   ( 5 0Institute of Internal Auditors, IIA1    $& 5'%   . ")   5(  %% % 5) 6 )  5 ##), )  6 $     ( 5    .   [email protected]%  [=: ::: &  [:: (.Institute of Internal Auditors !   5 " 6 5 " " 5   2 +  , #$ 5"( %% %    " ( 6 5"(  +& (   &     ( ( .Institute of Internal Auditors  $/ #  !  6 ) 56# ( .    6#$  5 6#%H K5") )  0Gertified Internal Auditor, GIA1, K")  65 "( #) 0Gertified Financial Services Auditor, GFSA1, K")  5 "( #) 0Gertified \overnment Auditing Professional, G\AP1, K5") #   # % 0Gertified in Gontrol //56 ")! ")! " !   3(41), 2010 ")! ")! " ! . .,  .X.,  R.R.  . RH &!5 -. .  .Q. )   3(41), 2010    ..*   3(41), 2010 %%  ") 5(   $  5% #, %  &!"  +  %,   & , !(5  &" #   &) ).  %    "!   % !5  %, ") !" &" % "5!"( ).  ' %, (&  5& (  5 %  )5 &  # +&  . Z)5")  %  5  +6 6 , % , &  5  " ( &"( [email protected].  %/ %,   & "(  !"(  5 )  %/ ! %  %) [email protected] ! , ("( 5  ). 5  +(  5) (    !  )) #, # +66  6 5(%) ) %5 ,  # 5,    %% & ( ')  ..- ) (& ) 65#) (  6#) + "%  ") 5 % '% &"( //56  /  & %.    3(41), 2010 [, 9, ;,..., n1,   !5 max j ij a x " 5  (" ) 1 ( ... ) 1 ( ) 1 ( 2 2 2 1 nj j j i x x r ) &  % //56 &  .  (  ". + !( "!   $, ")   )   . %  ") (  &"% #6&   , !" "!" , ($/ +66   %   . 5    .[. /  )5  !   %% % *R-  ,   ")  5  ?,9.  +66   %     %%$ % --- R 0   =,? " .!.7&.1, --- 5&  0+66   5&#x=,? ;&#xTj T;&#x* .1;ҁ ;&#xTw ;&#x".;&#x!.7&;&#x.1;&#x, --;&#x- ;&#x;&#x5T;&#xj T*;&#x .13; T;&#xw &;&#x;&#x 0+;f;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x5Tj;&#x T* ;&#x.345; Tw;&#x ;&#x%;&#x ;&#x ;&#x :,;&#x`000;%  :,`=[? " .!.71  2 R 065& [,9[1. ! 5"  % % "  %% %  % 2 Z$#") ,   +   5% 9,9; " .!.7&.  !,  % + %%  % !) % )  ( & 5 "  +66  (%) ) %  2 - )     %%. -# & "( &  6& 2 % :,:9;, & ' +  [,[C?   ?[ . 2 , %  ) 5   , %  % 9,;; " . !.7&., & ' �&   [ . X  % 2 - )   "  %%  % [:,9C " . !.7&, ��& ' +  [;,`   3(41), 2010  1 7,1016,0415,653,13   !  1,00647 35,68979,424780,13158 0,023590,22143 0,256010,00165 /! !  f0,014730,152460,35832   !, . L16,910,510,17,08  2  $   #  +&&  #  @ : G  %    !&, R6,6745,2438,575,7841 !    !- 2,34346,50044,15718,8458 0,1270,7960,6695,2750 /! !   - f0,0231,2091,18550,7886 A !      !, . %.  L10,42824,22713,7991,3232  3 * # $   #   #  R/max R/max  f/max fL/max L //56  4 (   #    #  ("   (! 0,14740,050390,159360,019310,43045  5 (! 0,726920,901760,706670,961750,324391,90302 ,  (  #   3(41), 2010 ATSON \.V. Strategic BenchmarkingH Vow to ^ate your Gompanys ��9. AI^I M. Benchmarking for Best Practice. OxfordH Butterworth5 ��;. XR2R - . ., ] R.K. % +&  H ���. 2RR Z-X Z ., . -#%, 5   3(41), 2010   ..**  )&  %,  )&  %, yt A a b:xt b[xt [ t {  %  5, &    )5   t 6 ') " % %,  +  !5  &  ( (5   #  G    3(41), 2010   &  "( #, + )  b9  ..  65 b ! $5 b b. b " ! $  % 5 (  5     6#$  %$/ %   6 yt , x9, ..., xi1 091  y x n f "!&" 5   &%  #   % %  ( %  K% % %% '( 6  & 5  %)  R, X   !" "" $/ " ' 6" % ) %H 1 [email protected]   "% %   "!#J !1   ) "!) #J 1  &"( 5"(  .K" 6" %%$ % (5" % %) "!) "'   5"  ! & ! 5!)) !" ! !5!"$/  .  " "  5(%) ) 5785  56   , &  5%) " X  "  5 & ) "  % 6 [email protected]   "%  & +66) 5& ) %  %)  % [email protected]   "5%, & [email protected]% % % #6)  . ""% !   "(  ( % 5#  "( 6  5  !%, %% "   ! &5 "   6. &"    ", &  5    (% 5%% "!) "'   )  ) !  %, !$ % & % 6 ') "  5  "( )  %  9, [C= .H1  %    $ $ % "!5 % "!) % "!5  1   A      0,62,20,1     1,10,30,5  =   1,90,42,7   3(41), 2010 x k c &  5 x K x K  )&")  65 0  � :,?  (%  5  5   ( %  (  !(    /  % '( 5785  56      +             @    + '           + '            +     !     '      +     !    '       )                            ! '      )   !    %''       +               ,&('5/(& "#$%"#&' #6+(' "#(-$++(&  2 9$  C H     I0,412,021,23  K H    I0,551,181,83  = H   I0,292,502,93 "!&       CH     I0,553,854,94   3(41), 2010 9$  K H    I0,574,763,61  = H   I0,341,392,07  C H     I0,443,532,43  K H    I0,691,121,50  = H   I0,272,623,44 QR R  . . R "( %   7   3(41), 2010   ..*   3(41), 2010 =J . ?.   &% 5) 6" 6% 5 " /$ %  ) #) !, ,  , % % 5& ) 6  +. Q5 &$ & ") " , %%$ % !", %"  5%#)   " ) %, " % % ". Z  #  # %   5%H    % 0! , +66 , &5   , # 1   0  !5 , 6 " 1 J . ?=.  " %   %$ 5 "  & ") 5# , $/)   5& !($ !$ %  !&$/) % ')  . X'% &    %   5) 0Performance Measurement System PMS1  "  $5&  ( ,  / $  ) 5  '  ". Z& ,   ,  6 "( %(   &%  "&  !",  &% EA  GF^OI.  / "(    6 #  5! &  5,   & 5" &%    65 )  .   , & $   5  6  $ ' ") .  & & ( &Y (  65%   " ) %  # +( )5 ), , " 5!" ( H !"   0effectiveness1, %"  5  5J !" +66  0efficiency1, %" # 5  # .!  % 5  0") 1  % !  5$/ H *%  %# 5  ) %J % &  65     J 2##%  5 ' #% 5 $!) #).!   % H -    +665   $  &)  % 5 5785  56  & % 65 & #5   3(41), 2010 5785  56      3(41), 2010 5785  56       &%,   &  %   3(41), 2010 Z2- .X. %   #. .H K, M.|. A short, practical guide to implementing strategy 77 T. and | I. Strategy5Process ^esearchH and W A.S. A performance measurement   3(41), 2010 &% %,  ,   &)   3(41), 2010   " &" !/) # , %   %    '% % "( &H  (  / /   3(41), 2010 5%"(,  &"(  %  &) ! # %  . 6%  6#%  , 5', ") (, / /  1 @     &      #$    ;      #$     N     !-     %  G   ,    , !           ,     %         &  ,     ,           !   ,   !& %& . N    !  -    O  !   %   !       !  ,     -  !&   ! O       !O    % O !   !          - !&O  -   &  !O      ! ! O     ! !   O  !-          % O     -    H! !   (%    H!  !    -     !   , !   !   %   ,      ,    !    ,    N   !   =    !       !        - N ,    $     G   ,    , !           ,     %    ! ,     ,  !     ,     %    ,       &  , !   ! ,    !      !  N ,   -  $   !& ;          !      !  ,         !   !,         , %      %   !,  -   3(41), 2010    ..** / / /(  &  "( ),  5 J 9  )  J ;  '  1   # &         &   1      (   3,30,53,0 +    0,50,11,0 =    3,80,64,0 F&   2,80,42,0 =   ! 4,10,6684,6 F&  ! 2,50,3321,3  2 *        #  +      -          &     # $ 11112,80,402,008,251,746 2P1113,80,402,008,853,362 31 P112,80,602,008,455,762 4P1P113,80,602,009,256,776 511P12,80,404,007,153,276 6P11P13,80,404,009,445,068 71P1P12,80,604,009,254,376 8P1P1P13,80,604,008,656,780 002,50,503,007,051,080 10P 004,10,503,009,545,068 110 03,30,333,006,632,042 120P 03,30,673,008,258,092 1300 3,30,500,138,053,980 1400P 3,30,504,607,953,780 150003,30,503,008,654,380 160003,30,503,008,654,180   3(41), 2010   # $ 170003,30,503,008,454,078 180003,30,503,008,755,084 190003,30,503,008,954,884 200003,30,503,008,654,282 C,=:` :,`[ :,99 :,:;; :,;;`[9 :,:CC ; :,:;C9; :,:;;[9 :,9=C99 :,:`;;9J 0[19 ?,9: :,`:[&#x:Tj;&#x 6.6; 0 ;� 6.;g 2;U.0;r ;ј.;ʼn&#x Tm ;&#x[Tj ;.5;&#x 0 0;&#x 11.; 25;.66;" 4;a.8;™ ;&#xTm ;&#x 9,; 9,=C9 :,=9?; [,9?:[9 :,=`?[; :,=`?[; [,:?:9; [,9?C[9&#x:Tj;&#x 6.6; 0 ;� 6.;g 2;U.0;r ;ј.;ʼn&#x Tm ;&#x[Tj ;.5;&#x 0 0;&#x 11.; 25;.66;" 4;a.8;™ ;&#xTm ;&#x 9,; 9,;[99 &#x:Tj;&#x 6.6; 0 ;� 6.;g 2;U.0;r ;ј.;ʼn&#x Tm ;&#x[Tj ;.5;&#x 0 0;&#x 11.; 25;.66;" 4;a.8;™ ;&#xTm ;&#x 9,; :,`; J 091 �[ C,:=99� ;,?; [,9?:[9 9,9?:[; ,9?:9; ;,=9=[9 =,[:999 [,?:;9, 0;1 [    %' (!,  % # &   ()   }9  ) (!5 ;  (    , &"    5"$, & & 5 )  ()     "( (   &'$ 65(& (  & ( 5) "( ).  +  "$   %      5&  ,  (%       %5'.      #5       !  &'$     5&   %    ,   " % !5 "")   .K% % ) #" (!  5 (( 6! !"    5, ") ! %  5 "( ) .  & O " / /   . 0?1  5  3 !      &  � ,   00    &   * & %! 70,0 A   ' 1,5 "  /   3,8 � &&  %     0,6 A  3,0 +  108,9  4  E -$       &      ,  64,281,0649,2 27,551,0278,3 1,381,013,9   3(41), 2010    ,  3,491,035,2 0,551,05,6  2,751,027,8 +  100,01010,0 %! ,            ;    & ( ! ?[? 9, 99[ ..Z"  % "(  5, &  ( &   [,9 [:9  ;,` [:  # 5 / /   3(41), 2010  5 )# &#-$     $  #     #   E  , . �42?42=0 12345 * !  , ?11,211,812,212,9 ;  , !23,523,023,023,0 610,0623,0630,0638,0 N        , !46,048,049,049,0 * %    , ;(S *C/C* 4,9.104 QF  .F  .4,0.104  ..  % $' T 30QF  .F  .T 30    %F % - & QF  .F  . * !  , ?11,011,612,412,4 ;  , !17,216,616,416,4 (%M  ,  3630,0648,0652,0658,0 N        , !48,049,049,050,0 * %    , *C/C* 1,3.102 QF  .F  .1,0.102  ..  % $' T 30QF  .F  .T 30    %1,0.10QF  .F  .0,9.10 * !  , ?10,611,211,611,6 ;  , !13,412,411,911,8 (%M  ,  3693,0703,0708,0710,0 N        , !49,049,052,053,0 * %    , ;(S *C/C* 5,0.104 QF  .F  .4,0.104  ..  % $' T 30QF  .F  .T 30    %T 5QF  .F  .T 5 A  !      &-    %    %   * !  , ?10,210,611,411,4 ;  , !17,016,616,416,4 (%M  ,  3698,0713,0718,0718,0 N        , !50,053,055,055,0 * %    , ;(S *C/C* 4,0.102 QF  .F  .3,2.102 = ..  % $' T 30QF  .F  .T 30    %1,1.102QF  .F  .0,9.102 Z2R --R .. Z! # ((  ) % 5% (!  )    )  '&)  �7 .. K  77   Z8. 9::. ~ `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mailH a.korotaevmail.ru   . .* /9:/,  6/  / 76 /   3(41), 2010 H #5+5 &!55 /9:/,  6/  / 76 /   3(41), 2010  5  ""  - (&  J Q* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;Q* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;  9[.:`.[` . ~ [[=5Q* - "') !    "(  "( [email protected]JQ* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;Q* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;Q* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;  :.:[.[= . ~ ;5Q* - #) !    %J Q* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;Q* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;Q* ;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD 0;&#x Tw ;&#x- ;&#x&;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#xJ;&#x Tj ;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ň ;&#xTw ;&#x  ; [.:;&#x`.[0;  ;:.:;.[ . ~ ?95Q* - 5+&  /9:/,  6/  / 76 / ;   3(41), 2010   3(41), 2010 ,    %.     5/) "  !%5   ",   /) &")  , @ ) "  ),  ! " "$   !     @5, %%$ '  )   $ !$"(    5      ) %%    !%  ) "    , 5! &  )  $     ,    5. &, &     ("     %    & ) "     ; ..*   ,     3(41), 2010 ��)  $/   9::: , & & 5  0  , & )    + #  ,  5 % %  &  5&%1 #    & ;. Z5   5  %1 /9:/,  6/  / 76 / &')  % $!  % / " "   '   # ,   ,    $"( ) ), (% ) )  " ", $ ' % '% , "$ % !%  �� H     5  (   &%      "     %, %  ") "  & $5 '%   ( +(  ,  & 5 ! %!"       /%    5("  ($ ) !     ,    ! . K   !" + 6",  $ ,   , % , &  "  "5 &    5 ,    . = 091  ) #  ( ) 5  [C: . 0  ) # [C: .1. 5  5   3(41), 2010 ,  ' %, $&   &. &5, &     //   ",   "  !%5     ,    $&    !/   "( !%  )      #   5  (   05/  1. 85&     '     &%   % &" ! 5%  ! 5"  &% !( 5 "( "( !%5      ,     .  +   !% % %   /)   ,      /)   . 2"  %$ 5     !%  ! '   $ +  % $ . 2&,     6#   5 %   5   $& % ,    5   ! &5 & ) ) .  " , " ! " 6 ,  " " " 0. dominansBdominantis 5 /9:/,  6/  / 76 / &)1   3(41), 2010 %    %&  &   $/( ) +  H " $, & %&    %    %  , &   "% ! ! " 0 1   % 0 )1 1       %   & %    /     ! !%  & . -!/  /9:/,  6/  / 76 / "  % ,  &  #$/( 6),   "(  (,    3(41), 2010 [. %&  Q.R. 9::`. ~ .9. &  Q.R. Z     "( !%5 (. R6.  . . $. . ., 9::C.;.    )  ) # 0 )1. 85 . 8")   . Z  H www.cisg5online.ch7   3(41), 2010   ..* #   ,   3(41), 2010 %  [email protected] /9:/,  6/  / 76 /   3(41), 2010 /9:/,  6/  / 76 /   3(41), 2010  % , &  /9:/,  6/  / 76 / -4RZ- .. R%  . !., 9::[. 9. X-4RZ- ..  , #,  0" +5 ��;. -XR K* R.R. #  . ., 9::=. . -XR K* R.R. #  #5& ) .. #   77  " 65 ��=. R 2R .X. " " 0 "( #%(   3(41), 2010        /9:/,  6/  / 76 /   3(41), 2010 )    ZQ  ` !% 9::[ . ~ C=:, 5  #") % %)    ! (%"( "( ),  .&. % %  " +&   /%  %  5" +& ( ), 5   "(  %  !  ! (%5"( "( ).  +  #$ "( 5%)  %  5 %  !).- " %% !  ! (%"( "( 5%( "  ( Q5"( (    5   ZQH Q")   [: %5% 9::9 . ~ `5Q* -! ( $/) " 0 .  . &#x .,;&#x 900; 99   9:: ., 9 !% &#x .,;&#x 000;9:: ., % 9::? .  ;[ !% 9::? .1J Q")   [ 5&#x ;Tj ;&#x-1.7;Α ;&#x-1.2;&#x TD ;&#x.259; Tw;&#x  ;&#x[000;&#x ;Tj ;&#x-1.7;Α ;&#x-1.2;&#x TD ;&#x.259; Tw;&#x  ;&#x[000; [? . ~ ;;5Q* -!  ! (%"( "( 5%( 0 .  .  ;: !% &#x ;Tj ;&#x-1.7;Α ;&#x-1.2;&#x TD ;&#x.259; Tw;&#x  ;&#x[000;9::[ .,  9 !% 9:: .  &#x . ;&#x Tj;&#x T* ;� Tw;&#x 000; % 9::? .1J Q")   9; 65&#x . ;&#x Tj;&#x T* ;� Tw;&#x 000;&#x . ;&#x Tj;&#x T* ;� Tw;&#x 000;% [? . ~ 9=5Q* - 5"( &!"(   (, &!5"(   %(  ( 0 .  .  99 5&#x . ;&#x 00;  9:: .  % 9::? .1J   5&#x . ;&#x 00;&#x . ;&#x 00;&#x . ;&#x 00;  ZQ  [ %!% [= . �~ [9 - % % 5      ! (%"( "( 5).  %/ %   5    ) K ZQ ( %   !  !"(   5#"( ( Z , !") 5  Q" R     Q" R5    !" +&  . +  ZQ "% %   -- ;H   " " ,  .&. ! 6"J #" J " J   " " J % "J &    !5&  "J &!5" [email protected]%%$ % /9:/,  6/  / 76 / + %%$ % 5 (" #" &%, (%/ %  #,  01 / &$ +& $ &" %  %  )#  )# [email protected]%% % 5 ")  , &")    & &"   "     3(41), 2010 5 %%$ % 5 /9:/,  6/  / 76 /  1  9#E     #  1. D!      ! 2. F  =&     - 3.   !  =&     - 4. D!      ! A          !- 5.     !=&        !-   3(41), 2010 /9:/,  6/  / 76 / -*Z  ..   % H &!  ! 7 .. 2"5   3(41), 2010   /9:/,  6/  / 76 / + #% !%     ,    ),   "(  & "( "( % %  "   "   , &      &     "  , &     / % % %$/ !'   % 0?:, '"(   3(41), 2010 �9::[ . ~ ?5Q* /   5, & &  , % )   "( #) %  " 5 0   1    "!(, %%$ % /9:/,  6/  / 76 /   3(41), 2010 /9:/,  6/  / 76 / %/ % )  %    !/  #  )    H " ",  ##, $", %   !" # ) $  $, "(.   (  )  !  , &  ),    $ + $  "$  $ ! 6$/ %   !/      3(41), 2010 85 �) ( %( 77 Z ) % . 9::[. ~ [;;. [ $%.9. Q")   [C % 9::? . ~ ?[5Q* - "!( 5   ) K" Q !% Z ) ) Q# 77 &% %   2 $ . X "( * . 6. X  %6.;. R! . !" # "!    5&#x $;&#x%.Tj;&#x 1.2;̤ ;&#x-1.2;&#x TD ;&#x.008; Tw;&#x 9. ;&#xQ;&#x;&#x" ;&#x;&#x  ;&#x[C ;&#x% 9;&#x::? ;&#x. ~;&#x ?[5;&#xQ* ;&#x- ";&#x!;&#x 5;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ঔ&#x Tw ;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#x;&#x K;&#x" Q;&#x;&#x;&#x ;&#x!;&#x% ;&#xZ;&#x Tj;&#x T* ;&#x.155; Tw;&#x Q;&#x#;&#x ;w ;&#x;&#x&;&#x% ;&#x;&#x% ;&#x;&#x 2;&#x;&#x;&#x$;&#x. Tj;&#x T* ;� Tw;&#x X;&#x ;&#x" ;&#x*;&#x;&#x;&#x;&#x. ;&#x. X;&#x ;&#x;&#x%;&#x6.;&#xTj 1;&#x.232; -1;&#x.2 T; -.;ݳ&#x Tw ;&#x;. R;&#x!;&#x ;&#x. ;&#x!;&#x" ;&#x;&#x;&#x# ;&#x"!;&#x ;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x ;Tj ;&#x-1.2;̤ ;&#x-1.2;&#x TD ;&#x.050; Tw;&#x ;&#x;&#x% ;�;&#x";&#x ; 7; ;&#x;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#x. ;&#x[000;&#x $;&#x%.Tj;&#x 1.2;̤ ;&#x-1.2;&#x TD ;&#x.008; Tw;&#x 9. ;&#xQ;&#x;&#x" ;&#x;&#x  ;&#x[C ;&#x% 9;&#x::? ;&#x. ~;&#x ?[5;&#xQ* ;&#x- ";&#x!;&#x 5;&#xTj -;.23;$ -;.2 ;&#xTD .;ঔ&#x Tw ;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#x;&#x K;&#x" Q;&#x;&#x;&#x ;&#x!;&#x% ;&#xZ;&#x Tj;&#x T* ;&#x.155; Tw;&#x Q;&#x#;&#x ;w ;&#x;&#x&;&#x% ;&#x;&#x% ;&#x;&#x 2;&#x;&#x;&#x$;&#x. Tj;&#x T* ;� Tw;&#x X;&#x ;&#x" ;&#x*;&#x;&#x;&#x;&#x. ;&#x. X;&#x ;&#x;&#x%;&#x6.;&#xTj 1;&#x.232; -1;&#x.2 T; -.;ݳ&#x Tw ;&#x;. R;&#x!;&#x ;&#x. ;&#x!;&#x" ;&#x;&#x;&#x# ;&#x"!;&#x ;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x ;Tj ;&#x-1.2;̤ ;&#x-1.2;&#x TD ;&#x.050; Tw;&#x ;&#x;&#x% ;�;&#x";&#x ; 7; ;&#x;&#x;&#x ;&#x;&#x;&#x. ;&#x[000;% 0") 1 77    . [=. ~ ?. . -- R..,  ..,  .., 4 . . /9:/,  6/  / 76 / .. &  ,   !/   =. K Z . &  H . 6#. ;5 . .H . . 5" #  %  ����. 2RZR  .. 2 #%  )5& % !5 - Z 2. #%   & 5 X K  .R., 2 .., . .   "5 Z- R . . #" "!"   )  5 Z--Z2 . . K%  &  . ., ��[. 4 Z 2- .R. #" "!"H  "!  )5   3(41), 2010     !         /9 6-/6  6 6   3(41), 2010 �% & 0=:1., =  $ % =:, !%$  &$  ! & ?. /9 6-/6  6 6 2. @#   . �5.     $.   3(41), 2010 0. Gontent manage5 ( "( S.Builder, uGoz, [X5  .  SiteEdit 5  ) 6 5" & % %, 6%  (&   5%,   + ! 5 !&%  6 "( . -!") ), ") /$ SiteEdit, &  " 5, %" % "( 5 ). , & SiteEdit %5% %  ) 25H  % &  "  5 %  $ 5  &       &% )5 ",  % &  "   %  5( 5!&. 2 %  %5    ) $ %,  + $&   !( ' % " , "( "(  6% ).4   %  , !  . - /9 6-/6  6 6 1#23-$ /4 $ http:55www.kafedra678.ru5 *      /     +        &  $    . 1. &#,&,#+ (%$0 +(#(++(3(6#)(/&$0+(?( #$,# $%# @(+(  ,"#/$+ + "#$%"#&! &(#?(/ @ b91 b; b b?, bi # 0 :  ? !1  5$/ %H b[ ), VTML5J J b 5   3(41), 2010  1 (      &    @  0= 59205216415208168206366101355420790157 74813767123319726 /9 6-/6  6 6   3(41), 2010 #5! ) 6" ! & "  %  % )  %) !"  &$ &! J  $ % "( %)  # #) % 0  "( ,  -X2-R ..  6#  !5 . .,  .. 6#" ( ..,  .X. 6#" (  !5 .X.  "( 6#"( /9 6-/6  6 6 .X.  %  " R   3(41), 2010 6/6 6 6 =/5 -   3(41), 2010 6/6 6 6 =/5 - rotection of creditors rights realized by means   3(41), 2010 The phenomenon of irrational adaptation in political Keywords : Nikonorov S.M. Ecological problems of the stable development tourism in the 6/6 6 6 =/5 -   3(41), 2010 candidate of economic associate professor of economics Chertkov A.S. candidate of historical sciences senior lecturer Chugumbaev R.R. candidate of economic senior lecturer Danchenok L.A. doctor of economic sciences professor �7 /9 6/ 6 candidate of science 0engineering1 Karh D.A. candidate of economic chair of commerce and rade economy. Kibitkin A.I. doctor of economic sciences honored worker higher school of ^ussia Korotaev A.S. candidate of science 0law1 Krasnoyarova N.I. candidate of law associate professor Kukukina I.G. doctor of economics professor Kulikov V.I. doctor of economics Professor of management department Kulikova O.I. Master teacher of management organization department ^ussian state university of trade and ekonomics Ivanovo Lobzhanidze A.A. Gandidat of political science associate professor the department of philosophy   3(41), 2010 190    3(41), 2010 Ɍɪɟɛоɜɚния оɮоɪмлɟнию ɪɭкопиɫɟй опɭɛликоɜɚния нɚɭчном жɭɪнɚлɟ Вɟɫɬник ɋоɞɟɪжɚниɟ ɫɬɚɬьи ɞолжно ɫооɬɜɟɬɫɬɜоɜɚɬь ɬɟмɚɬичɟɫким нɚпɪɚɜлɟниям нɚɭчномɭ жɭɪнɚлɚ оɛлɚɞɚɬь опɪɟɞɟлɟнной пɪɟɞɫɬɚɜляɬь инɬɟɪɟɫ шиɪокоɝо кɪɭɝɚ чиɬɚɬɟлɟй жɭɪнɚлɚ Рɭкопиɫь пɪɟɞɫɬɚɜляɟɬɫя ɪɟɞɚкцию элɟкɬɪонном ɞиɫкɟɬɟ ɮоɪмɚɬɟ Word Windows ɪɚɫпɟчɚɬки 14 шɪиɮɬом чɟɪɟз 1,5 инɬɟɪɜɚлɚ Поля лɟɜоɟ 2,5; ɜоɟ 1,5; ɜɟɪɯнɟɟ 2 Рɭкопиɫь ɛɭмɚжном ноɫиɬɟлɟ ɞолжнɚ ɫɬɪоɝо ɫооɬ ɜɟɬɫɬɜоɜɚɬь ɪɭкопиɫи мɚɝниɬном ноɫиɬɟлɟ ɪɭжɟния ɪɚɫɯожɞɟний ɪɟɞɚкция ɛɭɞɟɬ оɪиɟнɬиɪоɜɚɬьɫя элɟкɬɪонный ɜɚɪиɚнɬ ɪɭкопиɫи Оɛъɟм ɪɭкопиɫи ɞолжɟн пɪɟɜышɚɬь 812 ɫɬɪɚниц кɚнɞиɞɚɬɫкой ɞиɫɫɟɪɬɚции 15-18 ɫɬɪɚниц ɞокɬоɪɫкой ɞиɫɫɟɪɬɚции ɜключɚя ɬɚɛлицы ɝɪɚɮичɟɫкий мɚɬɟɪиɚл ɚнноɬɚцию лиɬɟɪɚɬɭɪы ɛɭмɚжном ɜɚɪиɚнɬɟ ɪɭкопиɫи ɞолжнɚ пɪиɫɭɬɫɬɜоɜɚɬь ɫкɜознɚя нɭмɟɪɚция ɫɬɪɚниц ɪиɫɭнкоɜ ɬɚɛлиц Ɍɚɛлицы ɬɟкɫɬɟ ɞолжны зɚɝолоɜки кɚжɞɭю ɬɚɛлицɭ ɬɟкɫɬɟ ɞолжнɚ ɫɫылкɚ Иллюɫɬɪɚции ɞолжны поɪяɞкоɜый номɟɪ нɚзɜɚния нɚпиɫɚнии мɚɬɟмɚɬи чɟɫкиɯ ɮоɪмɭл поɫɬɪоɟнии ɝɪɚɮикоɜ ɛлок ɫɯɟм ɞопɭɫкɚɟɬɫя ɪɚзмɟɪ шɪиɮɬɚ ɛолɟɟ Риɫɭнки ɫɯɟмы Инɬɟɪнɟɬɚ изɞɚɜɚɬьɫя ɛɭɞɭɬ Ƚɪɚɮики ɪиɫɭнки ɞолжны ɜыполнɟны ɬолько ɛɟлом цɜɟɬɟ ɪɚзмɟɪ ɞолжɟн пɪɟɜышɚɬь ɜɟɪɬикɚли ɝоɪизонɬɚли Мɚɬɟɪиɚл пɭɛликɚции элɟкɬɪонном ɞолжɟн ɫоɞɟɪжɚɬь ɬɟкɫɬ ɫɬɚɬьи ɪɭɫɫком языкɟ ɫлɟɞɭющɟй ɫɬɪɭкɬɭɪой пɟɪɜой ɫɬɪɚ пɪɚɜом ɜɟɪɯнɟм ɭɝлɭ пɟɪɟɞ зɚɝлɚɜиɟм нɟоɛɯоɞимо ɭкɚзɚɬь ɚɜɬоɪɚ ɭчɟноɟ зɜɚниɟ ɞолжноɫɬь мɟɫɬо ɪɚɛоɬы зɚɝлɚɜиɟ ɚнноɬɚция ɛолɟɟ ɫɬɪок ключɟɜыɟ ɫлоɜɚ 510 ɬɟкɫɬ ɫɬɚɬьи лиɬɟɪɚɬɭɪы концɟ ɪɭкопиɫи ɚлɮɚɜиɬном поɪяɞкɟ ɚɜɬоɪоɜ ɫооɬɜɟɬɫɬɜии ɫɬɚн ɞɚɪɬɚми ɛиɛлиоɝɪɚɮичɟɫкоɝо опиɫɚния ɋɫылки циɬиɪɭɟмыɟ иɫɬочники ɪɚзмɟщɚюɬɫя ɬɟкɫɬɟ ɫкоɛкɚɯ ɭкɚзɚниɟм номɟɪɚ иɫɬочникɚ ɫɬɪɚницы нɚпɪимɟɪ [1, Иɫɬочники ɭкɚзɚнныɟ ɬɟкɫɬɟ ɫпиɫкɚ лиɬɟɪɚɬɭɪы иɫключɚюɬɫя ɚнɝлийɫком языкɟ ɚɜɬоɪɚ зɚɝлɚɜиɟ ɚнноɬɚция ключɟɜыɟ ɫлоɜɚ ɫɜɟɞɟния ɚɜɬоɪɟ ɫлɟɞɭющɟй ɮоɪмɟ ɋɜɟɞɟния ɚɜɬоɪɟ ɪɭɫɫком языкɟНɚ ɚнɝлийɫком языкɟ Оɬчɟɫɬɜо ɍчɟноɟ зɜɚниɟ Мɟɫɬо ɪɚɛоɬы Зɚнимɚɟмɚя ɞолжноɫɬь Ɍɟлɟɮон Почɬоɜый ɚɞɪɟɫ Элɟкɬɪонный ɚɞɪɟɫ ɪɭкопиɫи пɪилɚɝɚюɬɫя ɞɜɟ зɚɜɟɪɟнныɟ поɞпиɫью ɪɟцɟнзɟнɬɚ пɟчɚɬью Рɟшɟниɟ пɭɛликɚции оɬклонɟнии ɪɭкопиɫи пɪинимɚɟɬɫя ɪɟɞколлɟ ɪɟзɭльɬɚɬɚм ɚнонимноɝо ɪɟцɟнзиɪоɜɚния Рɭкопиɫи ɫооɬɜɟɬɫɬɜɭющиɟ ɭкɚзɚнным ɬɪɟɛоɜɚниям ɪɟɞɚкциɟй ɜɚюɬɫя Плɚɬɚ пɭɛликɚцию ɫɬɚɬɟй ɜзимɚɟɬɫя Конɬɚкɬнɚя инɮоɪмɚция Рɟɞɚкция нɚɭчноɝо жɭɪнɚлɚ Вɟɫɬник E-mail: [email protected] Поɞпиɫной инɞɟкɫ жɭɪнɚлɚ Вɟɫɬник кɚɬɚлоɝɟ Аɝɟнɬɫɬɜɚ Роɫпɟчɚɬь ɍɜɚжɚɟмыɟ чиɬɚɬɟли Поɞпиɫɚɬьɫя нɚɭчный жɭɪнɚл Вɟɫɬник можно оɬɞɟлɟнияɯ ɫɜязи кɚɬɚлоɝɭ Аɝɟнɫɬɜɚ Роɫпɟчɚɬь Поɞпиɫной инɞɟкɫ ɪозницɭ жɭɪнɚл можно пɪиоɛɪɟɫɬи книжном киоɫкɟ ɚɞɪɟɫɭ Моɫкɜɚ ɋмольнɚя Выɯоɞиɬ ɟжɟмɟɫячно РОɋɋИЙɋКОȽО ȽОɋɍȾАРɋɌВЕННОȽО ɌОРȽОВО ЭКОНОМИЧЕɋКОȽО ɍНИВЕРɋИɌЕɌА НАɍЧНЫЙ ЖɍРНАЛ Оɬɜɟɬɫɬɜɟнный ɝлɚɜноɝо ɪɟɞɚкɬоɪɚ ɋɟмьяноɜ Рɟɞɚкɬоɪы ɍɪюпинɚ Ɏɟɞоɪоɜɚ Компьюɬɟɪнɚя ɜɟɪɫɬкɚ Лиɯоɛɚɛинɚ www.rsute.ru E-mail: [email protected]

Приложенные файлы

  • pdf 36337221
    Размер файла: 878 kB Загрузок: 0

Добавить комментарий